Support our Sponsors
St. John's Westchester Orthopedic Center
Letters-to-the-Editor & Commentary

Tell Aetna to Tell Sonya, “Sorry, Our Fault. Never Again.”

• Bookmarks: 29 • Comments: 1


September 21, 2023

In 1950, when she was a toddler, Sonya Abelaf Munroe’s immigrant parents

moved to Sleepy Hollow.  She and her husband raised their three children here,

across the street from their extended family — her parents, sister, and brother.

Support our Sponsors
La Catena Restaurant Ardsley - holiday parties

    In May this year, Aetna Medicare refused to cover surgery to remove a cyst

growing in Sonya’s spine.  Since March, it was squeezing the sciatic nerve to her

left leg, causing severe debilitating pain.

    Her surgeon scheduled its removal for May 31st.  “No,” said Aetna on May 16th.

“We won’t cover it until she first has 6 weeks of physical therapy.”  The surgeon

called that “Idiotic!”  PT doesn’t remove a cyst.

    On June 24th, Aetna changed their mind and approved the operation for July

18th.  The surgeon removed the peanut-size cyst that day, and her pain stopped.

    She sued Aetna in White Plains federal court, representing herself without a

lawyer.  She wasn’t asking for money but that the court declare Aetna responsible

for her 7 weeks of unnecessary suffering (from the cancellation of May 31st to the

surgery on July 18th); and that the court order Aetna (1) to apologize to her and

(2) to submit a protocol of how they will stop abusing patients like this.

    In August a White Plains trial judge dismissed the case, saying she must first

“exhaust her administrative remedies” through the Aetna appeals process.  Sonya

has appealed it to the superior court in Manhattan.

Submitted by her husband,

Patrick Munroe

Sleepy Hollow

Read or leave a comment on this story...


Support our Sponsors
  • Piccola Trattoria open for brunch - Dobbs Ferry
  • Andrea Martone's 2024 sales - Houlihan Lawrence Realty
  • Tranquility Spa - Scarsdale
  • La Catena Restaurant Ardsley - holiday parties

Irvington Resident Representing Rivertowns in NY Pageant

By Rick Pezzullo--- An Irvington resident will be representing the rivertowns in the upcoming 2025 Miss NY for America Strong...
Read More

More State Funding Sought for Road Safety Improvements

By Rick Pezzullo--- State Assemblywoman MaryJane Shimsky (D/Greenburgh) was among a slew of elected officials and union leaders who called...
Read More

Weremother

WEREMOTHER: Nightbitch & Yellowjacket By Krista Madsen Give me a long four-day weekend (Thanksgiving) and I’m most likely—as my former Home|body title...
Read More

Senior Dies in Condo Fire in Tarrytown

By Rick Pezzullo--- A 77-year-old woman was killed in a fire just after midnight Thursday at a condominium complex on...
Read More

Local Boys’ Hoops Team Looking to Hit Their Stride for Postseason

By Tom Pedulla--- The local high school boys’ basketball season is ready to get into full swing. Here is an...
Read More

Kendal on Hudson Renovation Project in SH Receives County Financing

By Rick Pezzullo--- A renovation project at Kendal on Hudson in Sleepy Hollow recently received a financial boost from Westchester...
Read More

Tarrytown Ranks High in Nation for Main Street Holiday Shopping

By Rick Pezzullo--- When it comes to rivertowns, Tarrytown is often mentioned as one of Westchester’s jewels. Now, Tarrytown has...
Read More

Girls Varsity Basketball Teams Enter Season with Optimism

By Tom Pedulla--- The local girls’ basketball season is tipping off. Here is a look at each team in the...
Read More

Students ‘Hit the Boards!’ at Irvington Middle School

By Rick Pezzullo--- When students at Irvington Middle School hear the phrase “hit the boards,” they enthusiastically dive into the...
Read More

Loscher Looks to Turn Around SH Boys Basketball Program

By Tom Pedulla--- Sleepy Hollow High School’s long-suffering boys’ basketball program, which may have reached its nadir with three-win seasons...
Read More
29 recommended
1 notes
360 views
bookmark icon