Support our Sponsors
Donate to The Hudson Independent
Letters-to-the-Editor & Commentary

Tell Aetna to Tell Sonya, “Sorry, Our Fault. Never Again.”

• Bookmarks: 35 • Comments: 1


September 21, 2023

In 1950, when she was a toddler, Sonya Abelaf Munroe’s immigrant parents

moved to Sleepy Hollow.  She and her husband raised their three children here,

across the street from their extended family — her parents, sister, and brother.

Support our Sponsors
La Catena Restaurant - Ardsley, New York

    In May this year, Aetna Medicare refused to cover surgery to remove a cyst

growing in Sonya’s spine.  Since March, it was squeezing the sciatic nerve to her

left leg, causing severe debilitating pain.

    Her surgeon scheduled its removal for May 31st.  “No,” said Aetna on May 16th.

“We won’t cover it until she first has 6 weeks of physical therapy.”  The surgeon

called that “Idiotic!”  PT doesn’t remove a cyst.

    On June 24th, Aetna changed their mind and approved the operation for July

18th.  The surgeon removed the peanut-size cyst that day, and her pain stopped.

    She sued Aetna in White Plains federal court, representing herself without a

lawyer.  She wasn’t asking for money but that the court declare Aetna responsible

for her 7 weeks of unnecessary suffering (from the cancellation of May 31st to the

surgery on July 18th); and that the court order Aetna (1) to apologize to her and

(2) to submit a protocol of how they will stop abusing patients like this.

    In August a White Plains trial judge dismissed the case, saying she must first

“exhaust her administrative remedies” through the Aetna appeals process.  Sonya

has appealed it to the superior court in Manhattan.

Submitted by her husband,

Patrick Munroe

Sleepy Hollow

Read or leave a comment on this story...


Support our Sponsors
  • Andrea Martone Westchester real estate agent - Tarrytown listing
  • La Catena Restaurant - Ardsley, New York
  • Piccola Trattoria open for brunch - Dobbs Ferry

Hundreds Have a Blast Enjoying Independence Day

Residents in Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow had a blast Friday at the village’s annual fireworks extravaganza at Pierson Park. Food...
Read More

Sleepy Hollow Resident Relishes Horse Stable

By Tom Pedulla--- Sleepy Hollow resident Larry Doyle was in the right place at the right time when he ventured...
Read More

Shining A Light On Asian Americans’ Influence On American History

By Jeff Wilson-- Watching a PowerPoint, “Hidden Voices: Asian American and Pacific Islanders in the United States,” a new component...
Read More

Fire Officials Oppose Battery Energy Storage System in Tarrytown

By Rick Pezzullo--- Local fire officials are continuing to throw cold water on a proposed Battery Energy Storage System (BESS)...
Read More

Residents Warned About Bear Roaming Around Tarrytown

By Rick Pezzullo--- When it comes to the bare necessities about being aware of your surroundings, residents in Tarrytown are...
Read More

Eremition

EREMITION: I'm sitting this presidency out By Krista Madsen Call it an existential crisis, or, in the vernacular of our times, a...
Read More

At Sleepy Hollow’s New DeCicco & Sons, Tally Makes Sure The Shelves Are Stocked

By Barrett Seaman— Tall and erect with a soft burgundy screen explaining that her role is to "check shelf inventory,"...
Read More

Sleepy Hollow High School Class of 2025 Graduates

The Sleepy Hollow High School Class of 2025 received its diplomas last week on the football field. The following is...
Read More

Drake to be Next Hastings Mayor after Winning Primary

By Rick Pezzullo--- Hastings-on-Hudson Trustee Tom Drake will be the village’s next mayor after defeating fellow Trustee Morgen Fleisig in...
Read More

Hastings-on-Hudson High Class of 2025 Graduates

The Class of 2025 at Hastings-on-Hudson High School received its diplomas last week. The following is a complete list of...
Read More
35 recommended
1 notes
464 views
bookmark icon