Local News

Pro-Choice Group Out to Take Down Carlucci

• Bookmarks: 20

May 30, 2020

By Barrett Seaman

Just as one candidate, Rye’s Catherine Parker, drops out of the race for District 17’s congressional seat, there is a new entry in the contest—and one that candidate David Carlucci is not going to like.

  • YMCA Circle of Caring event
  • Armonk Outdoor Art Fair

The Westchester Coalition for Legal Abortion (WCLA) Choice Matters, which has its roots in the fight leading up to Roe v. Wade nearly 50 years ago, has launched a campaign to highlight State Senator Carlucci’s seminal role in the creation of the Independent Democratic Coalition, the IDC, a group of eight elected Democrats in the State Senate who voted as a bloc with Republicans for eight years.

The lead entity in what has become a coalition of various pro-choice, progressive activists on both sides of the Hudson is ProChoice Voter. On Wednesday, the group launched a barrage of postcards—up to 15,000 to Rockland Democrats, 8,250 robocalls, with more to come, and live calls to as many of 14,785. While the impetus behind the campaign is Westchester-based and includes the Democratic Committees of Dobbs Ferry, Irvington and Tarrytown, it is aimed at Rockland voters, where most analysts see Carlucci’s strength. With the exception of a patch of Westchester around Ossining, the county constitutes Carlucci’s 38th New York State Senate district.

The messaging is an indictment of the candidate for “betraying Democratic principles” and “lying to his constituents about his role in the IDC”—specifically his role in blocking pro-choice, pro-feminist and other social justice initiatives like the Dream Act, the Climate and Community Protection Act, school funding, the Fair Pay Act and early voting. Because he abandoned Democrats in Albany, the group argues in its literature, “he cannot be trusted to fight for us in Congress.”

In its literature, ProChoice Voter does not endorse any of the remaining six candidates. The group’s backers no doubt have their personal preferences but are staying mum for the time being. “It’s our job to shave off a few thousand votes from Carlucci,” says Catherine Lederer-Plaskett, President of WCLA-Choice Matters. “It’s their job to sell themselves.”

The Carlucci conundrum for the others in this crowded race has always been his perceived dominance of Rockland. Though none of whatever private polling other campaigns have done has been made public, it is widely believed that they show not only his strength west of the Hudson but also a disconnect in voters’ minds between his congressional candidacy and his role in the IDC.

Even if this new entry into the fight succeeds in planting anti-Carlucci seeds, that leaves voters with six other choices, with little indication at this time which might break out of the pack in the next three weeks. Some party leaders, including the Democratic committees in Irvington and Greenburgh, are advising anyone who has not already voted my mail to hold off for a while to see if a new factor, like the anticipated New York Times endorsement, leads to a breakout. That and big questions about voter turnout, namely compliance with vote-by-mail rules and timing, leave this a very difficult election to predict.

Share the News!
Andrea Martone - Westchester and Rivertowns Real Estate - Houlihan Lawrence agent


By Barrett Seaman- Homecoming weekend is a big deal, and Irvington High School students were geared up for a big...
Read More

Hackley Football Team Aiming to Harness Talent 

By Tom Pedulla — Vic Quirolo, Hackley’s new football coach, calls it a “crazy scenario” that he inherited. And it...
Read More

Ultimate Guide to Halloween 2021 in Sleepy Hollow and the Rivertowns

By Brianna Staudt — Whether you’re a local anticipating a favorite Halloween tradition or a visitor looking to experience Halloween...
Read More

Sleepy Hollow Tarrytown Chamber Endorses Latimer for Re-Election

By Brianna Staudt — In a first, the Sleepy Hollow Tarrytown Chamber of Commerce endorsed  Westchester County Executive George Latimer...
Read More

Developer Chosen to Modernize Franklin Towers and Courts in Tarrytown

By Rick Pezzullo — The developer of an affordable housing project on the grounds of the YMCA on Main Street...
Read More

Boat Club Competes to Keep its Tarrytown Waterfront Home

By Barrett Seaman— For 65 years, the Washington Irving Boat Club (WIBC) has provided dockage for Tarrytown boaters, as well...
Read More

Inside Last Week’s Rivertowns Power Outage

By Brianna Staudt — The phone rang at 6:40 a.m. on Monday morning. Retiring Public Schools of the Tarrytowns Transportation...
Read More

The Indy Welcomes Brianna Staudt As Its New Editor

By Barrett Seaman-- The Hudson Independent is pleased to welcome Tarrytown resident Brianna Staudt as its new managing editor. She...
Read More

Sixteen Local Students Named 2022 National Merit Semifinalists

By Brianna Staudt — Dobbs Ferry, Irvington, Tarrytown and Sleepy Hollow combined to double their number of National Merit Scholarship...
Read More

Record Number of Dates Planned for The Great Jack O’Lantern Blaze

By Rick Pezzullo — The Great Jack O’Lantern Blaze kicks off the first of a record 59 nights today at...
Read More
20 recommended
bookmark icon


The Hudy Indy welcomes comments. All comments are held for moderation and may take a day or two to publish.