Support our Sponsors
BREAST CARE & SURGERY at St. John's Riverside Hospital
Government & Politics
Sleepy Hollow News

Mt. Pleasant’s Fight To Stave Off Sleepy Hollow Voting Rights Challenge Is Proving Costly

• Bookmarks: 86 • Comments: 4


September 29, 2024

By Barrett Seaman–

In a perfunctory 5-0 vote at its September 24 meeting, the Town Board of Mt. Pleasant authorized another payment to the international law firm of Baker Hostetler—this time for $343,738.82, covering fees incurred during the months of June and July. That brings the Town’s year-to-date legal bill for this case to over $1,075,000.

The money is for the firm’s work in defending the Mt. Pleasant against a lawsuit by five Hispanic residents of the Village of Sleepy Hollow, which is part of the Mt. Pleasant, alleging that its “at-large” system of electing board members systematically discriminates against Sleepy Hollow’s large Hispanic community, in violation of New York’s John R. Lewis Voting Rights Act. The case was brought by the firm of Abrams Fensterman LLP.

Support our Sponsors
  • Sunnyside Federal Savings - Irvington NY
  • Clocktower Players Irvington, New York
  • GymCats Westchester gymnastics gym

Two independent experts hired by the Town Board last year essentially agreed with the plaintiffs, noting that in the last six Town-wide elections, candidates supported by Hispanic voters prevailed in only one election. In all the others, the preferences of Hispanic voters were lost in a sea of predominantly white voters in the rest of Mt. Pleasant. Despite the considerable legal costs and a poor record nationally in defending against Voting Rights challenges, the board voted to fight it.

For background on this, go to: https://thehudsonindependent.com/mt-pleasant-grapples-with-sleepy-hollow-voting-rights-charge/;

https://thehudsonindependent.com/mt-pleasant-pays-300000-to-law-firm-to-cover-four-months-work-on-sleepy-hollow-voting-rights-case/, and:

https://thehudsonindependent.com/mt-pleasant-hires-national-law-firm-to-fight-allegations-by-sleepy-hollow-hispanics-that-the-town-is-violating-the-voting-rights-act/.

At the rate it’s going, the Baker Hostetler legal bill will almost certainly surpass $2 million by this time next year. Asked how long he expected the case to drag on, Town Supervisor Carl Fulgenzi allowed that he didn’t know. “The opposition keeps throwing stuff at us that has nothing to do with [the Town’s voting system]. The case has yet to go before a judge. “It’s a paper fight right now,” Fulgenzi says.

The one mitigating factor, he says, is that the town’s insurance policy is picking up the tab for “about half” of the legal bills.

Fulgenzi argues that changing the voting method from its current “at-large” method, in which all voters have equal standing throughout the town, to a “ward” system in which voting blocs, such as the villages, elect their own representatives, would set up a conflict of interest in which town board members elected by a village would potentially be faced with issues inherently against the interests of the villages they represent. That, says the Supervisor, “makes it difficult to represent the interests of those villages and those of the Town Board at the same time.”

Claiming that assertion “doesn’t make sense,” David Imamura, an attorney representing the Sleepy Hollow voters, counters that “you could make that argument about any level of government.”

Asked whether the town would consider another voting method, such as rank choice voting, the Supervisor said residents were “just confused by this.”

“To me,” he concluded, “the fairest way is what we have now.”

Read or leave a comment on this story...


Support our Sponsors
  • Piccola Trattoria Dobbs Ferry, NY
  • Temple Beth Abraham
  • Andrea Martone - Houlihan Lawrence Irvington Office
  • Dobbs Ferry Christian Pre-School

An Invitation to Tarrytown Voters to Participate in an Election Year Focus Group

The Hudson Independent is planning to convene a focus group of registered Tarrytown voters who could meet at a mutually convenient date and...
Read More

Dobbs Ferry Prevails in Emotional Homecoming Game

By Tom Pedulla--- On a night of roiling emotions as Dobbs Ferry celebrated the life of Sam Kearns and marked...
Read More

Irvington Author Revisits Roots With Book on Penn State Football

By Tom Pedulla--- Author Chris Raymond has lived in Irvington for almost 20 years. He never forgets his Scranton, Pa....
Read More

Dead & Company’s Oteil Burbridge Brings Musical Friends And New Jerry Garcia-Inspired Album To The Cap

By W.B. King-- When conceiving his introspective album, A Lovely View of Heaven, a heartfelt tribute to the musical legacy...
Read More

Local Land Trust Honors “Open Space Heroes”

By Barrett Seaman-- On a gorgeous Sunday afternoon, dozens of environmental activists from Irvington and surrounding villages gathered at the...
Read More

Crepuscular

CREPUSCULAR: Going out on a liminal By Krista Madsen– Ever since Flannery O’Connor packed so much meaning onto the toilet stall in...
Read More

The Irvington Theater Is Back In Business

By Shana Liebman-- After nearly five years, the 122-year-old Irvington Theater will reopen this fall. It’s a momentous occasion that...
Read More

Sleepy Hollow Street Fair Draws Masses

By Barrett Seaman— Midday traffic to the east was backed up to the Saw Mill River Parkway; to the south,...
Read More

Support-A-Walk to Celebrate 30th Anniversary Sunday

By Rick Pezzullo--- For the last 30 years, Support Connection has offered free and confidential emotional, social and educational support...
Read More

Local School Districts Fare Well in Nationwide Ranking

By Rick Pezzullo--- Five local school districts all earned high marks in a recent national ranking that reviewed districts in...
Read More

Tarrytown Lighthouse Open for Free Tours

By Rick Pezzullo--- For the first time since 2020, the historic Tarrytown Lighthouse in Sleepy Hollow will be open for...
Read More
86 recommended
4 notes
1221 views
bookmark icon