Health News

Have We Gone About This the Right Way?

• Bookmarks: 78

March 18, 2020

By Barrett Seaman

There are those who see the COVID-19 pandemic in the darkest of terms. The eminent physicist who also worked for decades in epidemiology, Dr. Richard L. Garwin, now 92 and living in Scarsdale, predicts the effects will be “much worse than the Great Depression.” There is a small minority, including thoughtful residents of the rivertowns, who may not disagree with that conclusion but question whether it had to be this way.

In addition to noting the high rates of infection and death during both the SARS and H1N1 epidemics, when no comparably extreme measures were taken in the U.S., these skeptics contend that the failure to be prepared to do widespread testing and the related failure to concentrate extreme precautions on the most vulnerable citizens—seniors over 70 and those with compromised immune systems, left governments with few options beyond a broad brush suppression of economic and social activity.

“When I look at the available facts,” says retired attorney Pat Gilmartin of Irvington, “the damage being done to our economy and social interactions by the draconian steps now in vogue, the statistics about flu, and see that South Korea has managed to control the virus without bringing millions of its citizens to the brink of bankruptcy, and watch the Wall Street traders have a feast because of the volatility caused by the actions taken and/or contemplated, I find myself wishing for a Maggie Thatcher who could inspire – or order — the nation to keep calm and carry on.”

Wayne Olson, chairman of the Foundation for Economic Education, a libertarian think tank formerly headquartered in Irvington, expresses a similar view: “There seem to be two approaches to the government’s response to the COVID-19 situation:  One, the targeted approach where they do aggressive investigation to figure out who’s sick and then quarantine those people, and two, the brute-force approach where they say, let’s not do widespread testing, let’s quarantine everybody and bring the whole economy to a halt.”

There are epidemiological experts who would agree that isolating the most vulnerable, combined with widespread testing of everyone else, and then letting the disease essentially burn itself out would have been an effective strategy. But it is one for which the country was simply not prepared.


Share the News!
Andrea Martone - Westchester and Rivertowns Real Estate - Houlihan Lawrence agent

Dows Lane Second Grader Honored

Dows Lane Elementary School second grader Hanani Lubin was awarded the New York State Office of the Attorney General Triple...
Read More

Westchester Tennis Ladder Brings Love of the Game to New Heights

By Shana Liebman– Game Set Match! The Westchester Tennis Ladder, which launched last summer with approximately 60 members, is gearing...
Read More

Irvington To Open Matthiessen Park To Non-Residents

By Barrett Seaman— The debate had gone on for over two years. One side, led by a progressive group, the...
Read More

Greenburgh Is Reassessing Properties Again

By Barrett Seaman-- They’re back! The envelope appears in the mail, bearing the telltale logo of Tyler Technologies, the company...
Read More

Irvington Theater Restarts Live Performances — Outdoors

This is the second in a series about the return of live performance art to the rivertowns. By Brianna Staudt--...
Read More

Tarrytown Music Hall Welcomes Back First Arts Patrons In-Person

The first in a series about the return of live performance art to the rivertowns.   By Brianna Staudt-- When...
Read More

The Legacy of Living in Someone Else Through Organ Donation

By Laurie Leavy--- The consideration of organ donation may be a difficult decision for some, or not a hard choice...
Read More

Sponsored by Mayor Brian Smith, Irvington Theater to Stream Broadway’s J. Elaine Marcos April 28-30

By Brad Ogden-- With ten Broadway shows under her belt, J. Elaine Marcos is a veteran of the theatre industry...
Read More

As COVID Wanes, Experts Assess The Mental Health Consequences

By Barrett Seaman-- Just as people emerge from their homes after a hurricane, looking around the neighborhood for downed trees...
Read More

A Very Good Homecoming at Sleepy Hollow High

By Kevin Brown-- Homecoming at Sleepy Hollow High School is usually associated with rowdy fans, a fierce football game, regaled...
Read More
78 recommended
bookmark icon