Donate to The Hudson Independent
Health News

An Ounce of Prevention . . . Is Worth a Vaccine!

• Bookmarks: 68

March 5, 2015

pet-vaccine| by Dr. Brian J. Green, DVM — Sleepy Hollow Animal Hospital |

In this age of vaccine hysteria brought about by the recent measles outbreak, a review of what is known, what is fact, what is feeling, what is faith, and what is incontrovertible is important. As it relates to our pets, however, dogs and cats do not claim religious exemptions, and feeling is usually less an issue since their pet parents don’t get the needle, so fact and fear is probably what we as veterinarians need to focus on most when discussing what measures are best for protecting our pets from some really, really nasty diseases.

Not wanting to immerse myself too deeply into the controversy on the human side, I will merely state that vaccines have a proven safety and efficacy profile based on millions of doses, hundreds of studies, and the fact that people who are not immunocompromised (defective immune system due to existing disease, genetics, chemotherapy, AIDs, etc.) will not contract an infectious disease that they have been properly vaccinated against. Further disclaimer: I do not work for the pharmaceutical industry, nor am I likely to unless offered a cozy place to work on a Caribbean Island, in which case we can talk about it over lunch – your treat.

What we do know on the pet side, is that in rare instances, certain vaccines have had side effects that make caution in their use tantamount. Cats receiving certain vaccines containing adjuvants (additives that increase the immunity in a killed vaccine) have been known to develop an aggressive cancerous growth at the injection site. In particular, the previously available 3-year rabies vaccines and some of the feline leukemia virus vaccinations that were adjuvanted were the most implicated. (As an aside, we at my animal hospital have never used an adjuvanted leukemia vaccine, and have not used the mentioned rabies vaccine since the first report came out). And occasional immune mediated diseases have been thought to have been vaccine induced, but most of the efforts to prove causality have been (as usual) in an extremely vocal minority.

So what is currently recommended for our pets?

The first question pet owners should ask themselves is has their veterinarian established the possibility of exposure to the disease? Some vaccines are mandated, but at what frequency? Should I vaccinate against a deadly disease if my pet is unlikely to encounter it just to be safe?

The answer to those questions is important, and the following recommendations are based on safety, exposure considerations, possible consequences of not vaccinating, and consequences of vaccinating needlessly.

‘Core vaccines’ are the vaccines that nearly every veterinarian will tell you are important. They include canine distemper/parvovirus (usually given in combination with several other components) and Rabies.

The former, though, much to the manufacturers disappointment, has been found to last 3-5 years (and sometimes beyond). Because of this, the more conservative among veterinarians, me included, recommend blood titers (levels) to measure protection until the vaccine is no longer protective, and only then revaccinating. This markedly decreases any chance of an adverse reaction to these ‘live, attenuated (weakened) vaccines’. The same is true of the feline distemper vaccine, the virus of which is, in fact, genetically similar (and might have originally mutated) to the canine parvovirus, both diseases being dramatically deadly when contracted. Blood titers of the feline vaccine are also advised in the same way.

Rabies vaccination is typically given as a 3-year killed vaccine to dogs, and until recently a 1-year (non-adjuvanted) vaccine in cats. Even indoor cats are required by law to receive this vaccine. A recent 3-year non-adjuvanted feline vaccine has been introduced, and may eventually replace the 1-year if safety proves equivalent.

So what are non-core vaccines, and when are they needed?

For cats, the only non-core vaccine currently recommended for potentially exposed cats is the feline leukemia virus vaccine. This disease is only transmitted cat to cat, usually via bite wounds and sexual contact, so strictly indoor cats need not apply. No other non-core vaccine is recommended by the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) or the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA).

In dogs, lyme vaccine is highly effective if hiking in woods, parks, aqueducts, etc. is a regular part of the dog’s life. Otherwise, good flea and tick control is probably adequate. The same exposure type applies to a disease called leptospirosis, which dogs contract by drinking from puddles contaminated by wildlife urine. This is an extremely deadly disease, contagious to people, that an effective vaccine can prevent if exposure is likely. Bordetella (kennel cough) is recommended for boarding and grooming sites, and canine influenza is advised for boarding and daycare facilities with high populations or rapid turnover. Corona virus is never indicated for any reason, and in this area, vaccines against rattlesnake venom is not given.

When all is said and done, your veterinarian is probably best positioned to guide you through the myriad of information and misinformation available on the internet. The fact that there is a potential conflict because he or she may profit from administering the vaccine should not come into it if the above guidelines are rigorously followed. If you are unsure, you may need to discuss your concerns with your vet, but it is far more difficult and much more expensive to cure some of these diseases than prevent them. And for the record, while breeders of dogs and cats are usually quite knowledgeable about pet care, they should not be your prime source for medical advice. And live pet retailers should be avoided completely, but that is an article for another day.

Read or leave a comment on this story...

Andrea Martone - Tarrytown, Sleepy Hollow real estate agent

Apartment Plan Near Tarrytown Train Station to Include More Affordable Units

By Rick Pezzullo--- The developer of a multi-family rental project proposed at 29 South Depot Plaza in Tarrytown has agreed...
Read More

Sleepy Hollow Trustee Race Gets Crowded

By Barrett Seaman— There are three open seats up for grabs in the March 19th election for the Sleepy Hollow...
Read More

Monster Mash

Monster Mash: When you bring the dead back to life By Krista Madsen– I have a confession to make that will get...
Read More

Annual Polar Plunges Raise $90K for Worthy Causes

By Rick Pezzullo--- Dozens of brave souls recently stripped down to take a dip in the frigid Hudson River for...
Read More

Irvington Police Crack String of Auto Burglaries

By Barrett Seaman— A recent string of thefts from unlocked cars, mainly on Dogwood and Sycamore in Irvington, had yielded...
Read More

Harrison to Retire from Irvington School District

By Rick Pezzullo---- Dr. Kristopher Harrison, who has led the Irvington School District for the last 12 years, is retiring...
Read More

Redistricting Commission Proposes (Not-So) New Map

By Barrett Seaman--- After months of hearings and internal deliberations, the New York State Independent Redistricting Commission (NYIRC), led by...
Read More

Five Champion Wrestlers Put Sleepy Hollow on the Map

By Tom Pedulla-- Silas Corveddu had done well merely to reach the Section 1 Division 2 championships on Feb. 10...
Read More

Masters Boys Basketball Is Earning Respect

By Tom Pedulla-- If it takes a tooth or two for The Masters School to continue its ascent in boys’...
Read More

TEENSCAPE 2024 – 7th & 8th Grade Summer Travel Camp

TEENSCAPE is a travel camp for current 7th & 8th graders. The program includes two sessions that are varied enough...
Read More
68 recommended
bookmark icon