Arts & Entertainment News & Events
Sleepy Hollow News

A New Hal­loween Ghost Story: Mostly True as Far as You Know

• Bookmarks: 82

October 7, 2019

by Elaine Mar­ran­zano –


It was a weird Hal­loween. For one thing it was snow­ing. The “white Hal­loween” of 2011 blew in on a Nor’easter which dumped 12 inches of snow on Westch­ester. Trees that still had their leaves caught the snow and snapped un­der the weight. Power lines were down, and I had one of the strangest ex­pe­ri­ences of my life.

  • Abbott House Awards Dinner
  • Irvington Theater Videos for Change

Some­thing odd al­ways hap­pens on Hal­loween. When I was 10, a group of adults in black robes came to our door and snatched the candy bowl full of witch­es’ fin­gers and choco­late eye­balls right out of my hands. My mom, dressed as Dolly Par­ton, chased them down the street in cow­boy boots and fake 44DDs. That was pretty en­ter­tain­ing.

But the year of the Hal­loween bliz­zard was some­thing else en­tirely. My mom dug out the Christ­mas wreaths and hung them on the porch along­side the witches and pump­kins. We made a sign wish­ing every­one “Merry Hal­loween.” Ly­ing in bed later that night, af­ter the rev­el­ers had given up and the streets were mostly silent thanks to the soft snow, I heard some­thing. Clop, clop, clop. Sounded like a horse to me, but surely the Head­less Horse­man was by now safely back in his grave un­til next year. Clop, clop, clop. I heard it again and headed out to see what was go­ing on.

The air was cold and misty, sort of what I imag­ine Lon­don weather to be. I started down De­vries Av­enue, the best street in the Manors in my opin­ion. I have seen coy­otes and deer on this street. Once a herd of es­caped sheep were seen rel­ish­ing their short-lived free­dom on De­vries. But un­less the Head­less Horse­man de­cided to stick around, I was­n’t sure what horse I heard or even if it was a horse. Then I saw hoof prints in the mid­dle of the road.

I fol­lowed them down De­vries, up Broad­way and then onto Pocan­tico Street where they stopped in front of the Morse school. Stand­ing in front of the build­ing where I went to sec­ond and third grade, I looked around for a horse. It could­n’t have just dis­ap­peared. The mist was get­ting thicker, mak­ing it hard to see. I walked hands out­stretched, try­ing to feel my way out. What hap­pened next was in the mar­gins be­tween a dream and full con­scious­ness.

Ris­ing from the mist in front of me, like an ocean liner, was a large brick build­ing in the mid­dle of the Morse school play­ground. It did­n’t make any sense. That build­ing was­n’t there yes­ter­day. I was sure of it.   Rub­bing my eyes in dis­be­lief, I stood frozen in place un­til the sound of a strik­ing clock shat­tered the si­lence and sent me stum­bling back­wards.

“You al­right, son?”

An el­derly man was reach­ing out his hand to help me up.

“You look like you saw a ghost,” said the man who ap­peared to be in cos­tume. His high-waisted pleated pants, plaid cow­boy shirt and striped tie looked more like 1940 than 2011.

“I don’t know what’s go­ing on,” I stam­mered. “How did that build­ing get there?”

“Well, it’s been there since 1900. That was old high school un­til we built Morse in 1922. Now it’s the high school.”

I thought surely this man was men­tal. Morse was not the high school. The high school was up on the hill over­look­ing Broad­way. Every­one knew that.

Just then a lit­tle white pony with brown patches saun­tered up.

“This here is Snow­ball, said the man, giv­ing the pony an af­fec­tion­ate scratch on the head, and my name is Johnny. We live right over there on the cor­ner of Howard Street. Where do you live?”

He pointed to a small yel­low house with a tin roof and a small sta­ble in the back yard.

“I live in Sleepy Hol­low,” I an­swered.

“Sleepy Hol­low, huh,?” he seemed be­mused. “This is North Tar­ry­town, al­ways has been, al­ways will be as far as I know.”

My head was spin­ning.

“Are you sure you are feel­ing okay son?”

It was all too much. I felt dizzy. When I reached out to steady my­self, that pony sunk his teeth in my up­per arm.

The pain jolted me awake and I bolted. I ran all the way home, check­ing be­hind me to see if Snow­ball was in pur­suit or if a flam­ing pump­kin was aimed at my head. This was Sleepy Hol­low af­ter all. I burst through the door and breath­lessly told Mom every­thing. At the men­tion of Snow­ball, she stopped me.

“Did you say Snow­ball? Was the man’s name Johnny?” she asked.

“That’s it,” I cried. How could she have known?

She flipped through the pages of a book from the His­tor­i­cal So­ci­ety and pointed to a black and white pho­to­graph.

“Is this who you saw?” she asked.

I looked closely and gasped. There, star­ing back at me, was Snow­ball and Johnny in a photo from the 1950s. Johnny was wear­ing the same cow­boy shirt and striped tie and, ac­cord­ing to the cap­tion, Snow­ball had been the pony mas­cot of the North Tar­ry­town High School foot­ball team since 1941. Mom flipped through the pages again and showed me a photo of a large brick build­ing with a clock tower on its roof stand­ing in front of Morse school.

“You must be mak­ing this up,” my mother said. “They tore that old build­ing down more than 60 years ago. And there is no way you could have had a con­ver­sa­tion with Johnny and Snow­ball. They have been dead for decades.”

I was stunned. Could I re­ally have imag­ined every­thing? Then I re­mem­bered.

“But Mom,” I said. “Look.” I raised my sleeve to re­veal a horse-teeth-shaped welt on my arm.

What’s the ex­pla­na­tion? Who knows? Maybe there was some­thing mag­i­cal in that rare Hal­loween snow storm that roused Snow­ball and Johnny from their slum­ber and al­lowed them to re­turn to a time, ever so briefly when Sleepy Hol­low was still North Tar­ry­town and I was not yet born.

Share the News!
Andrea Martone - Westchester and Rivertowns Real Estate - Houlihan Lawrence agent

Election 2021: Experiences with Village Motivated Bartolacci to Seek Office

By Rick Pezzullo — When Peter Bartolacci submitted plans to construct two-tiered retaining walls in the rear and side yards...
Read More

Recipe: Farmers Market Fall Pasta

By Linda Viertel — Before everyone dives into squash recipes, apple pie baking and root vegetable roasts, take time to...
Read More

Homecoming Night a Treat for Horsemen Football Fans

By Kevin Brown — Last Friday night (Oct. 8), the world seemed back to normal at Sleepy Hollow High School....
Read More

Mercy Adjuncts Escalate Pay, Benefits Dispute

By Brianna Staudt — Picket signs and hand-distributed flyers greeted cars at the gate of the prestigious Ardsley Country Club...
Read More

Senior Captain Regalado Big Reason Dobbs Ferry Has High Hopes

By Tom Pedulla--- Jose Regalado’s father, Francisco, would not allow him to play football until he reached the sixth grade...
Read More

Sleepy Hollow Says Good-bye to Chick Galella

By Brianna Staudt — Family, friends and neighbors laid beloved World War II hero and public figure Armando "Chick" Galella...
Read More

Greenburgh’s First Town Hall Farmers Market Attracts Hundreds; Encore Thursday

By Linda Viertel — Hundreds of shoppers flowed through the parking lot at Greenburgh Town Hall for the first ever...
Read More

Former Mayor Fixell Endorses Brown in Tarrytown Mayoral Race

By Rick Pezzullo — One of the three candidates running for mayor in the Village of Tarrytown recently received a...
Read More

Five Express Interest In Developing Property Leased by Boat Club

By Barrett Seaman— The Washington Irving Boat Club was joined by four other parties in submitting RFQ/RFI (Request for Qualifications/Request...
Read More


By Brianna Staudt — Sleepy Hollow may be host to "The Legend (of Sleepy Hollow)," but locals of North Tarrytown...
Read More
82 recommended
bookmark icon